The 1% Club’s Brutal Compass Puzzle Eliminates 16 Contestants in Just 30 Seconds
Sixteen contestants were knocked out of The 1% Club after failing to solve a tricky question involving three compass images. The 40% challenge required players to identify which image could never be turned into a correct compass, regardless of how many times it was rotated or flipped.
Hosted by Lee Mack, the ITV quiz show is known for testing logic and common sense rather than general knowledge. But this particular puzzle proved difficult for a significant number of players, prompting viewers to describe it as a “killer question”.

Could You Solve the Compass Challenge?
In the episode, contestants were shown three compass images and asked:
“Which of these images can never produce a correct compass image, no matter how many times you rotate it or flip it?”
With only 30 seconds to work out the answer, players had to look closely at the direction of each compass point and consider how the images would change when turned or reversed.
Ultimately, 16 contestants were eliminated after choosing incorrectly.
Mack revealed that the correct answer was B. The key was the relationship between the cardinal directions: when North and South are positioned correctly, East and West end up reversed.
The puzzle caught out not only contestants but also viewers watching at home.
One viewer took to X to write: “That was a killer question. #The1PercentClub.”
Another admitted: “The 40% question has beaten me & I’m out again. This middle section is brutal.”
The reaction highlighted just how challenging a question rated at the 40% level could be, even for viewers confident in their problem-solving abilities.

Two Finalists Walk Away From a £94,000 Jackpot
The episode also featured a tense final round in which two contestants faced a difficult decision: attempt the 1% question for a chance to win the £94,000 jackpot, or leave with £10,000 each.
Both chose the guaranteed money rather than risk walking away with nothing if they answered incorrectly.
Mack then revealed the question they had decided not to attempt:
“Yolande takes one tablet on every day of the week that has three vowels in total in it. She starts this pack on 2nd March. What date will she need to start a new pack?”
As the solution was revealed, one of the finalists, Sara, discovered that she had actually worked out the correct answer. Had she taken the risk, she would have missed out on the guaranteed £10,000 but stood a chance of winning £99,000.
Sara explained her decision to Mack, saying: “I wanted to not go home empty handed.”
Although she appeared disappointed after learning she had solved the final question correctly, Mack tried to reassure her.
“I still think you’ve done the right thing considering how difficult these questions can be,” he told her.

Other Quiz Show Questions That Have Left Contestants Stumped

The compass puzzle is just one example of how television quiz shows can turn seemingly straightforward questions into difficult tests of reasoning.
- Who Wants to Be a Millionaire: Earlier in 2025, viewers criticised a question they considered one of the show’s worst. Host Jeremy Clarkson asked which letter could not begin the surname of a woman who had won the Best Actress Oscar from the 2000 awards ceremony onwards. The options were G, K, M and W. Contestant Glen, who had secured £32,000, chose G — correctly identifying the answer. Nicole Kidman, Frances McDormand and Kate Winslet were among the actresses who had won the award since 2000.
- The 1% Club: Another question asked contestants to work out Amir’s birthday in January using the dates given for Edna, born on 6 April, and Jen, born on 15 October. The solution depended on counting the words in the sentence: the sixth word corresponded to the 6th, the fifteenth to the 15th, and Amir’s birthday to the 24th word. His date was therefore 24 January.
- The Chase: The ITV daytime quiz once asked which food someone with a nightshade intolerance should avoid. The choices were sweetcorn, potatoes and carrots. Contestant Steve selected sweetcorn, but the correct answer was potatoes.
These challenges demonstrate how quiz shows can test more than memory. Contestants must often recognise patterns, interpret wording carefully and make decisions under pressure — all while knowing that one mistake could cost them a substantial prize.
The 1% Club airs on ITV1 and is available to stream on ITVX.