Derek Hough Breaks His Silence As Dancing With The Stars Pros Accuse Him Of Phoning It In — After His Viral Admission About Giving Contestants Nines While Exhausted, The Judge Faces Growing Backstage Frustration Over His Scoring And Lack Of Constructive Feedback

Derek Hough is defending his commitment to Dancing With the Stars after a viral video sparked criticism of his judging, while new claims suggest professional dancers are becoming increasingly frustrated with his approach.
The controversy intensified following the show’s semifinals, with questions emerging about Hough’s scoring decisions and demanding schedule outside the ballroom.
Derek Hough Addresses His Viral Scoring Admission
During a TikTok livestream shared by professional dancer Ezra Sosa, Hough acknowledged that exhaustion had influenced his approach to scoring.

The judge explained that he had slept only three hours after travelling from Seattle while balancing his touring commitments and television appearances.
He then suggested that his fatigue was why he had been awarding contestants nines.
The remarks quickly attracted attention, raising concerns about whether his scoring accurately reflected the performances.
Speaking to Us Weekly after the semifinals, Hough pushed back against suggestions that he was not fully committed to the competition.
He insisted that anyone familiar with his live performances and television work would recognize his consistent dedication, emphasizing that he always brings 110 percent energy to his professional commitments.
DWTS Professionals Frustrated Behind The Scenes

Despite Hough’s explanation, an unnamed source told The Sun that several professional dancers have become unhappy with his judging this season.
According to the insider, much of the frustration centers on Hough praising contestants while awarding lower scores without providing sufficient constructive criticism.
The source claimed that the dancers struggle to understand what improvements he expects because his feedback offers little specific guidance.
The insider also alleged that Hough has appeared less enthusiastic on set than in previous seasons, contrasting his current demeanor with his traditionally energetic personality.
While fellow judges Carrie Ann Inaba and Bruno Tonioli were described as explaining their lower scores, the source accused Hough of simply going through the motions.
A Growing Controversy Ahead Of The Finale
The allegations have placed Hough’s judging under increased scrutiny at a crucial stage of the competition.
Although Hough maintains that his commitment remains unchanged, the anonymous backstage complaints suggest a growing disconnect between his intentions and how some professionals perceive his feedback.
With the Dancing With the Stars finale approaching, the controversy now extends beyond individual scores to a larger debate over whether contestants are receiving the guidance they need from one of the ballroom’s most experienced judges.